Friday, October 23, 2026

The open door and the closed mind: liberalism in an age of ideological conquest



Liberal societies rest on a promise; that people of every belief may live side by side, argue freely, worship as they choose, and leave one another in peace. It is among the finest achievements of human history. It is also a promise that depends on something it rarely says aloud, which is that everyone who enters the arrangement agrees to keep it.

That is the problem now facing the West and large parts of Africa. A tolerant society is not defenseless by nature, but it can become defenseless by habit. It can come to believe that tolerating everything is the same as being good, and that the mere act of questioning who is arriving, and what they intend, betrays its principles. The philosopher Karl Popper saw the danger decades ago. A society that extends unlimited tolerance even to those preaching intolerance will eventually see tolerance destroyed, and the tolerant with it.

The question of reciprocity

Start with a simple moral intuition. Liberalism asks us to treat others as we would wish to be treated. But what is owed to a movement that, wherever it holds power, denies to others the freedoms it demands when it is a minority? A Christian, a Jew, a secular dissenter, or a convert out of Islam cannot openly practice or preach in many places where political Islam dominates law and culture. Yet the same ideology, once it reaches a free country, invokes freedom of religion, freedom of speech, and protection from discrimination to advance its position.
None of this condemns ordinary Muslims, most of whom want only to work, raise their families, and live in peace. The point concerns political movements that treat liberal freedoms as a ladder to climb and then kick away. A free country has every right to ask whether those it admits, and those it empowers, accept the rules that make freedom possible: equality of the sexes, freedom to leave one's faith, freedom to criticize religion, and the rule of one law for all.

The African front

The danger is not abstract in Africa. ACLED, the conflict monitor, reports that jihadist violence in the Sahel is spreading toward Africa's western coast, and that Sahelian and Nigerian jihadist groups are gradually merging into a single, interconnected conflict environment stretching from Mali to western Nigeria. Analysts tracking the northwest of Nigeria describe a surge in jihadist activity across the North-West and North-Central regions in the first half of 2026. 

The toll is grave, though the numbers are contested. Advocacy groups such as Intersociety claim that more than 3,000 Christians were killed in Nigeria in the first eight months of 2026, and some church leaders call it a genocide. The Nigerian government replies that terrorists attack all who reject their ideology, Muslims, Christians, and those of no faith alike. Both claims contain truth, and honest analysis has to hold both. Christian communities in the Middle Belt and the north have suffered enormously, and so have Muslims who refuse the militants' version of their faith.  

What African liberal elites, and the Western institutions that advise them, often lack is the will to name the ideology doing the killing. When governments, NGOs, and media describe such violence only as "farmer-herder conflict," "banditry," or "communal tension," they spare themselves an uncomfortable conversation, and they leave the victims unprotected. A society that cannot name its enemy cannot defend itself.

The European front

In Europe the threat is less a matter of mass violence than of slow erosion, with sharp episodes in between. Terror attacks and plots tied to Islamist ideology continue; Austrian authorities, for instance, have recently pursued suspects for membership of terrorist organizations, incitement, and dissemination of Islamic State propaganda. Beyond violence lies a quieter contest. Security services have grown increasingly concerned about non-violent Islamists, and even sympathetic analysts note that small, well-organized networks can capture a school, a mosque, a council or a charity and use it to discourage integration and impose religious conformity on other Muslims nearby. 

Here the critique of liberalism has real force. For decades, many Western governments confused multiculturalism with the abandonment of expectations. They funded parallel institutions, tolerated segregated communities, and avoided enforcing basic civic norms, from equal treatment of girls to the prohibition of forced marriage, for fear of being called intolerant. They treated integration as optional and assumed it would happen on its own. In many places it did not, and the casualties of that neglect include Muslim women, apostates, and reformers who needed the state's protection and did not receive it.

What a confident liberalism would do

The answer is not to abandon liberalism, which would hand victory to the very forces opposed to it. The answer is a liberalism that remembers it has borders, laws, and a culture worth defending. Concretely, it would mean:
First, serious vetting and selective immigration policy. Admitting people is a privilege a nation grants, and it may weigh whether applicants and sponsoring networks accept its core civic principles. Asylum should remain a refuge for the persecuted, but it should be administered competently, with real checks and real removal of those who abuse it or commit serious crimes.

Second, enforcement without apology. Laws against incitement, forced marriage, honor violence, and extremist recruitment must be applied evenly, including in communities where officials fear the accusation of prejudice. Foreign funding of ideological institutions should be transparent.

Third, integration as an expectation. Language, schooling, civic education, and equal participation in the economy should be conditions of settling, with support offered in return.

Fourth, protection of dissenters inside every community. The most important liberal act is often defending the Muslim reformer, the woman who refuses the veil, and the convert who fears for her life, since they are the front line of the argument.

Fifth, solidarity with Africa that is more than rhetoric. That means security cooperation, support for local governments willing to confront extremist networks, and honest reporting on who is being targeted and why.

The deeper failure

At its root the danger is not a foreign ideology alone but a domestic loss of nerve. Liberalism fails when it forgets why it exists. It exists to protect the dignity of the individual against every form of coercion, whether from a king, a mob, or a creed. A liberal who refuses to defend that principle against an illiberal movement, because the movement wears religious clothing, has not become more tolerant. He has simply stopped being a liberal.

The choice is not between an open society and a closed one. It is between an open society that knows how to defend itself and one that will not survive its own generosity.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Words only truly come alive when they find an echo. If these pieces touch something within you, please share your thoughts below. Your voice is a vital thread in the tapestry of this space, and I would love to know what stirred inside you as you read.